2021-09-23 CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA ar;0
LE 1 D
•
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
AGENDA
THURSDAY, September 23, 2021; 2.00 PM
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS
3519 LIBERTY DRIVE, PEARLAND, TEXAS 77581
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN OF A REGULAR MEETING OF THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF PEARLAND, TEXAS,TO BE HELD ON SEPTEMBER 23, 2021 AT 2:00 P.M.
AT PEARLAND CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 3519 LIBERTY DRIVE PEARLAND,
TEXAS FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONSIDERING THE FOLLOWING NUMBERED ITEMS.
2021-17 Call to Order
2021-18 Directors Report
2021-19 Citizen Comments
2021-20 Approval of Minutes from the June 16, 2021 meeting
2021-21 - Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 017 to
provide for the audio/video recording of Civil Service meetings
2021-22 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question #4
2021-23 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#11
2021-24 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#60
2021-25 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question #84
2021-26 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question #85
2021-27 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#95
2021-28 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#99
2021-29 Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 022 of the
local rules
2021-30 Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 081 of the
local rules
2021-31 Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 025 of the
local rules
2021-32 Adjournment.
In compliance with the Americans With Disabilities Act, the City of Pearland will provide for
reasonable accommodations for persons attending Meetings. Requests should be received 48
hours prior to the meetings. For special assistance, please call Human Resources at 281-652-1763
48 hours prior to the meeting so as to make appropriate accommodations.
I certify that a copy of this notice of the Civil Service Commission meeting for September 23, 2021
was posted at City Hall, 3519 Drive, Pearland, Texas 77581, by September 20, 2021 by 2:00 P.M
Crystal N Roan, TRMC, CMC
City Secretary
C, It rE'_�Re •
[PEAK-AND
r E X A 5 ' 1
fsT. is,
a
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-2 I Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 017 of the local rules.
The Commission hereby orders.
The adoption and publication of the rule change as discussed
V The adoption and py blic ion of tile proposed rule change as amendegj
-1-0 rOViCte ►mo t O UCil0 re-COrdi 9t .vl xxvi
14 (1s '�
No change in the rule presented
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
\11 A
Pt
,,sac, Commission Chair
_a",,,ae.- ",•4f
Charles McMurrey, Vice Chair
f4GIomssioni
v .,.1 0
11PEARLPND
T. E X A
'
4Sr. 1S9b.
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-22 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#4 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Matthew Mattocks.
The Commission hereby orders.
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
✓ and requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A B C D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling,while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Serv. e Commission
Phil Ce s c, Commission Chair
CA/n44‘"'"?
Charles McMurrey, Vice Chair
ames Gi ert, Commissioner
di
V O
(:1iE ..._t . AND
.-- T E. X A 5'''
Sr.4 189A
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-23 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#11 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Matthew Mattocks.
The Commission hereby orders.
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
and requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A B C D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling, while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
P s c, Commission Chair
Charles McMurrey, Vice Chair
41
/ James Gilbert, Commissioner
`BOA pl.4.te
v O
T E X AS
Fs r l'8 9a
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-24 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#60 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Matthew Mattocks.
The Commission hereby orders:
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
Iand requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A B C D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling,while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
P
Phil 3 s , Commission Chair
C4 AAA,/
Charles McMurrey, Vice Chair
James Gi bert, Commissioner
,,,gY
ilpmaANDI
E X A 5
4.S t89'
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-25 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#84 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Jefrey Bond and Officer Matthew Mattocks.
The Commission hereby orders:
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
and requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A ✓B .'C ./D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling,while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling, sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
�I
Ph ►e- ommission Chair
harles McMurrey, Vice Chair
ames Gilbert, Commissioner
:moo I PEg4'
,;1
IIPEAR(fMD1
E X A
EST. I$9A
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-26 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#85 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Matthew Mattocks.
The Commission hereby orders.
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
Iand requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A B C D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling,while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
Ph e s , mission Chair
harles McMurrey, Vice Chair
mes Gilbert, Commissioner
4.poi N rE9,f• `9ti
11 1,- E Aa AN Di
v o
, T E X A S'
fsr. 1 s'a
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-27 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#95 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Jefrey Bond
The Commission hereby orders
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
/ and requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
✓ promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A B C D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling, while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
\ 4
Phil t i
.S:C, C.•• ission Chair
Charles McMurrey, Vice Chair
44,, / /i
James Gilbert, Commissioner
iii:t.• „,f
4.
OirE
7 E X A S
Est. is9°`
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-28 Consideration and Possible Action appeal of Sergeant Exam Question#99 from the
promotional examination of August 19, 2021 by Officer Jefrey Bond
The Commission hereby orders.
The answer key be sustained This Ruling which rejects the appeal presented to the Commission
/ and requires the Director to accept the answer as given on the answer key, while grading the
promotional examinations of all eligible candidates.
The answer key be overruled This ruling sustains the appeal presented The Commission
hereby designates answer(s) A B C D to be accepted and requires the
Director to accept a different answer or accept two (2) or more answers, as directed in the
Ruling,while grading the promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
The elimination of the test question This Ruling sustains the appeal presented The
Commission requires the Director to disregard the question and its answer while grading the
promotional examination of all eligible candidates.
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
Phil Cess , Co 1 • n Chair
Ceiiiim
harles McMurrey, Vice Chair
a ,
wi
dames Gilbert, Commissioner
��of \ P�,94.
v o
LPEAkI .,: ..* ,1
-`T E X A S.
FSr, is'9a
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-29 Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 022 of the local rules.
The Commission hereby orders:
The adoption and publication of the proposed rule change as presented
✓ The adoption and publication of the proposed rule change as amended
No change in the rule presented
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
Ik .
iiii it sac, Commission Chair
ar :s McMurrey, Vice Chair
James Gi ert, Commissioner
41 it
p,
11P' MID!
' T E X A 5
E's r. I S
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-30 Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 081 of the local rules.
The Commission hereby orders
/The adoption and publication of the proposed rule change as presented
The adoption and publication of the proposed rule change as amended
(Clltg 4-0 R4A/Ltli)
No change in the rule presented
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
1 14 illi" U Cessac, Commission Chair
A� harles Mc urrey, Vice Chair
W
OF James Gilbert, Commissioner
A.C) lk 9
IPEIP AND
TEX n s "---
fST, cot*
Civil Service Commission
City of Pearland,
3519 Liberty Drive,
/ Pearland, Texas 77581
September 23, 2021
2021-31 Consideration and Possible Action regarding revising Section 025 of the local rules.
The
Commission hereby orders.
adoption and publication of the proposed rule change as presented
The adoption and publication of the proposed rule change as amended
No change in the rule presented
This order is issued and signed by all concurring members of the Civil Service Commission
1
ii
Phil les ,c, Commission Chair
ai/WitrA
harles McMurrey, Vice Chair
f2, ..
James Gi ert, Commissioner