2017-07-11 CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION MEETING MINUTESCITY OF PEARLAND
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION FOR THE CITY OF PEARLAND, TEXAS, HELD ON
WEDNESDAY, JULY 11, 2017 AT 5:00 P.M. IN THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CONFERENCE ROOM, 3519
LIBERTY DRIVE, PEARLAND TEXAS.
Present
Phil Cessac - Chairperson
Charles McMurrey - Vice -Chairperson
James Gilbert
Michelle Graham - Director of Civil Service
Appealants
Sgt. Ornaldo Ybarra
Sgt. Juddson Kennimer
CALL TO ORDER Meeting was called to order at 5:00 p.m. by P. Cessac
2017-08
Appeal Hearing for Lieutenant Promotional Exams
Sgt. Ybarra was allowed to state his reason(s) for appealing questions #31. He requested to
see the test writer's response. He reviewed the response and stated his case. Sgt. Ybarra
stated that B and C were the only answers that can be correct.
M. Graham stated that others may speak regarding question #31.
Dacy and Dunham both made statements. Both agreed that D is the correct answer and
Dunham asked that it remain eligible.
5:18 P.M. C. McMurrey motioned to move into Executive Session. J. Gilbert seconded motion. P. Cessac
opposed. MOTION CARRIED 2/1
5:23 P.M. — Meeting reconvened. P. Cessac called the meeting back in session.
C. McMurrey made motion to sustain the question. J. Gilbert seconded motion. MOTION
CARRIED
Sgt. Kennimer was as allowed to state his reason(s) for appealing question #48. He states that
A is the correct question and give his supporting reason. J. Gilbert clarifies how the question is
written and Kennimer continued to support his reason for appeal. C. McMurrey asked to
move forward to question #60. Kennimer states his reason for appeal and there was
discussion regarding his response.
5:36 — P. Cessac motioned to move to Executive Session. C. McMurrey seconded motion. MOTION CARRIED
5:41 — Meeting reconvened. P. Cessac called the meeting back in session.
Minutes Page2
2017-10
J. Gilbert makes a motion to eliminate question #48 from the exam. C. McMurrey seconded
motion. MOTION CARRIED
C. McMurrey makes a motion to sustain question #60. J. Gilbert seconded motion. P. Cessac
opposed. MOTION CARRIED 2/1
M. Graham states that updated list will be posted within 24 hours.
Approval of minutes for the June 28, 2017 meeting
P. Cessac motions to approve minutes as written. J. Gilbert seconded motion. MOTION
CARRIED
J. Gilbert motioned to adjourn. P. Cessac seconded motion. MOTION CARRIED
Adjournment 5:50 P.M.
Approved on the n\ day of �pR. , 2018.
1‘
irif
Phil essac, n
Wit/WI
C. McMurrey, Vice Chairperson